How BetterHelp’s Therapists Mistreat LGBTQ Patients
In the summer of 2020, when Jenna Rodarte felt that she could finally trust her therapist with the truth about her sexuality, she expected them to be understanding. After all, the teletherapy service she was using—BetterHelp—advertises that its therapists “specialize in specific issues such as … family conflicts [and] LGBT matters.” And Rodarte had clicked “Yes” on BetterHelp’s intake survey when asked whether she wanted to be matched with “a therapist who specializes in LGBT issues.”
So when she finally mustered the courage to tell her therapist that she was part of the LGBTQ community, she was surprised by their response.
“I didn’t know this,” the therapist replied with a shocked look, according to a class action complaint filed by Rodarte in 2024. “Did you say this in your questionnaire?”
Rather than accepting Rodarte’s sexual orientation, the therapist, according to the lawsuit, began suggesting that Rodarte avoid reading books that feature “female friendships” because they could be “pushing an agenda.”
They also told Rodarte to avoid walking through parks because it puts her at risk of being assaulted, though the complaint does not make it clear whether this particular advice was because of Rodarte’s sexuality. When it came to Rodarte’s mental health, the therapist said spending time in church and with family would help, despite Rodarte’s earlier disclosures that she was not religious and found spending time with her family to be anxiety-inducing.
Rodarte wrapped up that call feeling full of shame and guilt and eventually canceled her subscription.
The allegedly homophobic attitude Rodarte’s therapist directed at her was not an isolated incident among providers on BetterHelp, which describes itself as “the largest virtual teletherapy platform in the world.”
Uncloseted Media reviewed more than 6,000 consumer complaints, some filed with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Better Business Bureau and others posted across social media platforms, and found more than 80 LGBTQ people who say they are former BetterHelp patients who had harmful interactions with therapists on the platform. Uncloseted’s review of dozens of posts and hundreds of comments across five platforms show that LGBTQ patients have been posting complaints about their BetterHelp experiences since at least 2018.
They describe sessions in which they were told to suppress their sexuality, that their sexuality was “freaky” and that their families wouldn’t accept them. Others report being told to attend church or to find a different therapist. And a few social media users say their therapists attempted conversion therapy on them or refused to acknowledge their gender identity.
“I’m not surprised in the slightest,” said Erica Curry, a therapist BetterHelp tried to recruit in 2024. Curry is licensed in California, Colorado and Florida, and has been providing therapy services for almost 10 years. “When mental health is not monetarily valued to begin with, we can’t then be giving so much money to a tech company,” Curry added. “Is that a mental health platform? I don’t think so. … To me, that’s just a soul-sucking company that’s trying to drain an industry of its light and love and how much these people like myself [therapists] like to help people.”
How BetterHelp Boomed
While teletherapy services have existed in some form for decades, they became mainstream during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Therapy by text messaging, video or phone calling can be beneficial for some LGBTQ people. It provides a workaround for closeted people who fear an in-person session could out them and for folks in rural areas who would live too farto see an in-person therapist that specializes in LGBTQ issues.
The advertised lower fees for remote therapy are also appealing given that 1 in 5 LGBTQ adults in the U.S. live in poverty. The national average cash-pay rate for psychotherapy is $143 per session, while a subscription to BetterHelp costs between $70 and $100 a week.
When BetterHelp launched in 2013, there were only a handful of other major teletherapy platforms available to the general public.
BetterHelp slowly emerged as a top provider because it was simple to join and promised access to “counselors who are specialized in specific issues, such as stress, anxiety, relationships, parenting, depression, addictions, eating, sleeping, trauma, anger, family conflicts, LGBT matters, grief, religion, self esteem and more.”
The company quickly caught the attention of industry leaders and was acquired in 2015 by Teladoc, a telehealth giant worth around $700 million at the time. Teladoc focused on scaling up BetterHelp’s operations, and made it the company’s primary direct-to-consumer mental health product in 2022. That same year, BetterHelp reported over a billion dollars in annual revenue.
The pandemic presented a business opportunity that Teladoc seized. Isolation orders and an effective marketing campaign boosted BetterHelp’s global monthly paying users to almost 400,000 by 2022. The platform peaked at just over 470,000 monthly users in early 2023 when it also reported a network of about 32,300 licensed therapists.
BetterHelp calls itself “the world’s largest therapy service” and is hailed as the “most recognized virtual mental health brand amongst U.S. consumers” by its parent company in its Securities & Exchange Commission filings. Last year, the platform reported $950.4 million in revenue.
When asked to comment on the findings in this story, a BetterHelp spokesperson wrote that the company “has helped more than six million people access convenient, affordable mental health support.”
“We believe everyone deserves respectful, high-quality care across all communities. Our therapist onboarding process includes an assessment of cultural competency, and we expect all therapists to provide respectful, professional care. When concerns about therapist conduct are raised, our process is to escalate them to our Clinical Operations team for review, with corrective action taken when warranted. We also work with clients to understand their experiences and do what we can to make things right.”
Multiple LGBTQ People Report Negative Experiences
Some of the controversies BetterHelp faces today can be traced back to business practices that eroded the public’s trust in the platform.
For one, a 2023 FTC investigation into BetterHelp’s data sharing practices found that the company “used information concerning approximately 600,000 Pride Counseling Visitors’ or Users’ mental health statuses and their connection with the Visitors’ and Users’ LGBTQ identities to optimize future advertisements for the Service on Facebook.” Pride Counseling was BetterHelp’s subsidiary dedicated to the LGBTQ community.
The FTC alleged that the company gave a recent college graduate working as a junior marketing analyst “carte blanche to decide which Visitors’ and Users’ health information [such as responses to BetterHelp’s intake questionnaire, whether or not they ultimately signed up for services] to upload to Facebook and how to use that information.” When the FTC released the details of its findings, the analyst had been promoted and was overseeing BetterHelp’s “use of Facebook’s advertising tools.”
Across consumer complaints, a common theme was issues with the platform’s intake questionnaire and subsequent therapist matching. BetterHelp says it“matches members based on preference, clinical experience, and 10+ years of expertise, using a powerful data-driven algorithm. The result? A highly effective match made in as little as 48 hours.”
Despite being touted as an easy way to help patients connect with the therapist that matches their needs, hundreds of the complaints reviewed by Uncloseted Media were filed by patients that were paired with therapists that did not fit the patient’s preferences, clinical needs or expectations of professionalism.
Dr. Pratik Bahekar, president of the Association of LGBTQ+ Psychiatrists and assistant professor at Yale University, told Uncloseted Media that mismatches are inevitable when algorithms rely solely on what patients say they are struggling with and what therapists say they are interested in treating.
Take, for example, a patient that says they struggle with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) who gets matched with a therapist because the therapist says they have experience treating people with OCD.
“If you do more screening, like for example there is something called PHQ-9 which screens for depression, [and] if the same patient has scored very high on the PHQ-9, meaning that the patient is very depressed, but the patient is saying, ‘I have an OCD problem’ … then the match won’t be ideal,” says Bahekar.
According to a TikTok posted by Andrew Hardiman in November 2020, he turned to BetterHelp for help with his anxiety and depression and was matched with a therapist that reportedly worked with LGBTQ clients. The first red flag, Hardiman said in his post, was when his therapist said “we needed to stop creating fake labels,” when identities like “cisgender and heterosexual were the same thing.”
Like Hardiman, Kendahl Landreth got matched with a therapist after specifying in her intake questionnaire that she wanted someone who specialized in LGBTQ issues. It wasn’t until 20 minutes into their third session, Landreth explained in a now-deleted TikTok video, that the therapist noticed Landreth had put that she was a lesbian in her intake form. In that same TikTok, Landreth says her therapist told her she was “freaked out” by her sexuality.
Caleb Hill, a gay man from Tennessee who was 22 years old when he used BetterHelp, told The Wall Street Journal (WSJ) that he also requested a therapist with LGBTQ expertise. Instead, he was paired with someone who suggested he repress his sexual orientation. “He said if I chose to go back to who I was and deny those feelings, he could get me where I needed to be,” Hill told WSJ, adding that the therapist said if he was gay, it would make reconnecting with his family difficult. Later, Hill found the therapist’s private website, which advertised faith-based counseling services. Hill’s therapist told WSJ that he cannot comment on confidential patient matters.
Telling Hill to go back in the closet, renounce his sexuality and rejoin the family that he described to his therapist as homophobic is a practice that organizations like the American Psychological and Psychiatric Associations, The Trevor Project and the World Health Organization recognize as a form of conversion therapy.
Countless academic reports and government studies conclude that LGBTQ people who have undergone conversion therapy face an increased risk of suicidality, substance abuse and other trauma-induced symptoms.
Dozens of posts like Landreth’s and Hill’s have cropped up across TikTok, Instagram, X and other social media platforms. They’ve garnered hundreds of comments from other users sharing their experiences, which in turn have received tens of thousands of likes: @LewisDruid wrote on YouTube that their therapist “tried to convince me that somehow all of my issues with my family members were because my mom was pretending to accept my sexuality.” @tegan_does_lites wrote on Instagram that she wanted to discuss her feelings of dysphoria but was told by her BetterHelp therapist that she “didn’t test high enough to be trans.” And a third patient wrote on TikTok that their therapist said they were “confused” because they were nonbinary and should consider getting back in touch with their estranged parents.
Other Marginalized Communities Report Similar Experiences
Queer patients are not the only ones saying that they are being paired with therapists that do not match the preferences they put in their intake surveys.
Both Tanaye White and Andreia Gibau were looking to be paired with a Black therapist, and ideally a woman, because they felt they would connect better with someone they did not have to explain their identities to.
White joined BetterHelp at the end of 2021 when she was under a lot of stress, trying to process several deaths in the family due to COVID-19 and a resurgence in her brother’s drug addiction. Despite her requests, White says she was bounced between white therapists and distracted therapists where she says it was not uncommon to be asked to repeat a thought.
White says at one point she could see the reflection in her therapist’s glasses. “She was watching TV.”
Gibau was stunned to find that her first BetterHelp therapist could not sit still during their session. Gibau had logged on for an introductory session, ready to open up about how she had just won the 2020 Miss New York USA beauty pageant and was daunted by the uncertainty of what came next—but the therapist “would literally bounce back between the kitchen and a seat at the dining room table.”
“I remember being like, ‘Oh if this is a bad time, we can reschedule,’ and she said, ‘Oh no, no, no, it’s fine, it’s fine,’” Gibau told Uncloseted Media.
These experiences are reflected in many of the thousands of other complaints reviewed by Uncloseted Media.
Experts say a therapist that isn’t sensitive to LGBTQ experiences may have compounding effects on the mental health of queer patients.
“When someone has a negative experience in therapy that they feel like they can’t discuss directly with their therapist, not only does the client not get the treatment they need but they might also develop feelings of hopelessness that their condition can never be treated adequately or appropriately,” John Pachankis, a professor of public health and psychiatry at Yale who also directs the university’s LGBTQ Mental Health Initiative, told Uncloseted Media. “Negative experiences in therapy might also reinforce the very problems that the client was seeking help with in the first place.”
Screening Processes and Pay Rates
In Gibau’s experience, she didn’t feel like the company took her complaints seriously.
“After the second therapist, I had reached out to the BetterHelp people, like their customer service, and just kind of shared my sentiments with them,” Gibau says. “It was just so dumb and they were like, ‘Oh my god, we apologize, here is 5% off your next session.’”
According to one former BetterHelp therapist, the best way to improve patients’ experiences is by updating the screening process for therapists looking to join the platform.
During the application process with BetterHelp, “there was a very short quiz that seemed like it was supposed to be testing your clinical knowledge, but it had very simple questions on it. … I remember thinking that even if applicants didn’t know the answers themselves, there was also nothing stopping them from just googling the answers,” the therapist, who asked to remain anonymous out of fear of retaliation, wrote to Uncloseted Media.
The rest of the therapist’s onboarding process consisted of completing a case study—the answers to which she believes could be easily found online—and a short meeting she believed was part of the screening process, to be followed by a full interview. Except she was never contacted for another interview; instead, she got the job and began working at BetterHelp.
When she moved on to work for other therapy providers, she found the differences in recruitment processes to be night and day. Some had her talk about different kinds of treatment approaches “in addition to live case questions and a thorough review of [my] professional history,” she says.
Pachankis says proper vetting of a therapist or mental health professional is an important step in ensuring LGBTQ patients get appropriate care.
“Working with clients who are experiencing challenges related to their sexual orientations and/or gender identities or expressions would require being trained in identity-affirming psychotherapies that have a significant evidence base for reducing depression and related outcomes among LGBTQ clients,” says Pachankis.
That kind of education is hard to come by, according to a January 2025 peer-reviewed study for PLOS ONE that found that the average amount of time spent on LGBTQ-specific education across all healthcare disciplines is 4.75 hours—which researchers described as a “concerningly low” amount of time. At the same time, half of queer adults report that it was difficult to find a therapist, either virtually or in person, that could relate to their life experiences.
“This is just my opinion; there are a lot of licensed mental health professionals that shouldn’t be,” says the former BetterHelp therapist.
Erica Curry believes BetterHelp’s quality issues stem from its attitude towards therapists. She found the pay rates offered to be woefully inadequate for the level of education required and workload she was expected to take on, but was not surprised because she views BetterHelp as a tech company focused on profits.
“They’re like, ‘Well, if you just work to the bone and you do like 40 clients a week, you could end up making like $116,000 a year,’” Curry remembers a BetterHelp recruiter telling her when she pushed back on an offered rate of $45 a session. “I guess it’s technically ethical to see 40 clients in a week, but I don’t know how you’d ever provide a good level of care seeing that many people.”
“We cannot have these major tech industries saying, ‘We’re going to take a huge cut of your pay because we’re giving you these clients even though you’re doing all the work,” Curry adds.
Lack of Industry Regulation
Apart from BetterHelp’s own standards, there are few regulations that hold the company responsible for negative patient experiences and therapist misconduct. This is largely due to the company’s business model, which positions itself as a third party.
On its website, BetterHelp says that the providers on its platform “are independent practitioners who are neither our employees nor agents nor representatives. The Platforms’ role is to operate the Platform and enable the Therapist Services, by providing the necessary technical and administrative support. The Company does not directly provide Services and is not a healthcare entity.”
Instead, a “clinical entity” called Uplift Behavioral Health, P.C.—a “100 percent physician-owned independent” entity—operates Teladoc’s BetterHelp telehealth provider network.
According to Dr. John Torous, director of the digital psychiatry division at Harvard’s Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, BetterHelp’s self-definition makes it harder for legislators to define these kinds of platforms.
“It is tricky,” Torous told Uncloseted Media. “What are these? Are they a practice of medicine, are they medical devices?”
This confusion is intentional, says Torous, and is what led the U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of New York to find that the teletherapy company Cerebral, Inc. had “encouraged the unauthorized distribution of controlled substances from 2019 to 2022.”
“A lot of these companies don’t want to be regulated. They don’t want to have to open up what’s happening and we saw that when Cerebral had to open up its books to the Department of Justice,” Torous added.
The experts interviewed for this piece did not have a particular take on how legislators should categorize teletherapy platforms like BetterHelp, but did agree that patient outcomes should be the number one priority.
The only legislation that Teladoc currently considers risky to BetterHelp’s business is two bills passed in Oregon and California in 2025 that block management service organizations, hedge funds and private equity groups from directing the scheduling or compensation practices of professional medical entities. Teladoc’s 2025 financial filings acknowledged that these laws could have a “material adverse effect” on the company if it cannot adapt its business model to new regulations.