When Siblings Believe LGBTQ Rejection Is an Act of Love
Jessica Everhart remembers sitting in silence for two hours as her sister and her sister’s boyfriend drove through Oklahoma toward a conversion therapy camp.
Everhart, who was 15 at the time, knew being gay was a sin because of her upbringing. She remembers asking where they were going. “[To] get you the help you need,” her sister responded.
Raised in a devout Church of God family, Everhart had long believed something was wrong with her. As a child, she remembers praying herself to sleep, “just begging God to be normal, like everybody else.”
After her father caught her on a date at McDonald’s and discovered she was gay, she says she spent three months at the camp where her sister dropped her off. She still bears scars from electric shock therapy she says was administered on her several times in attempts to “cure” her so-called same-sex attraction.

“None of [my family] ever cared about what happened,” she says. “I still have a scar on my breast, where they shocked me.”
Nearly 15 years later, when Everhart came out as transgender, her sister asked, “Are you sure you want to do this?” adding that God would abandon her if she continued in this direction.
The sisters stopped speaking for good that day.
“To her, her distancing herself is loving me,” Everhart, now 37, told Uncloseted Media. “But for me, I always internalized that I wasn’t enough for them. … I always remember that car ride, and panicking.”
Siblings are often the first family members LGBTQ peoplecome out to, offering a critical source of acceptance when parents may not. According to a 2025 Pew Research Center study, 69% of LGBTQ adults say all their siblings who know about their identity are accepting.
Still, religious beliefs can complicate those bonds. A 2014 study found that more frequent religious attendance predicted lower acceptance of gay or lesbian siblings. And in conservative religious families, siblings can become enforcers of their parents’ beliefs, sometimes viewing rejection as an act of love.
This rejection can leave wounds for queer people. A 2019 study found that greater sibling acceptance was associated with lower odds of suicidal ideation for trans youth, and a 2023 study found that sibling rejection, independent of parental rejection, was associated with higher levels of depression.
For siblings who were close growing up, that rejection can be especially painful, says Karen Gail Lewis, a therapist who specializes in sibling relationships. Siblings are often a person’s “first peer love relationship,” she says, and their bond is typically the longest of their lives.
“That hole is there, and it’s going to interfere with loved ones, with a partner, with a lot of your life,” Lewis told Uncloseted Media.
Siblings Can Help or Hurt
Research shows LGBTQ people often come out to siblings before parents, and siblings can help ease the emotional distress associated with coming out,mediate family conflict and help parents better understand their LGBTQ children.
A 2022 Trevor Project survey found that 54% of LGBTQ youth who were out about their sexual orientation reported support from a sibling, compared to 48% from a parent or caregiver. And a 2022 dissertation by Sloan Okrey, a social worker and assistant professor at St. Catherine University, found that 13 of 17 LGBTQ participants raised in conservative Christian families came out to a sibling before their parents.
For Brian, who asked that his last name be withheld to protect his familial relationships, his younger sister was the first relative he felt safe telling he was gay. Raised Southern Baptist in New Mexico, he had known he was gay since childhood but did not come out to her until his mid-20s.
Although his sister believed homosexuality was sinful, she supported him and kept his secret for more than a decade before he told their mother.
“I felt like she’s from my generation, so she might get it more,” Brian told Uncloseted Media. “I was struggling hard during that time frame with depression and being upset and feeling like there’s something wrong with me. And she was very supportive and told me to just keep trying and keep going.”
Jake Tacher, 35, grew up in a conservative Christian church that taught him being gay was acceptable, as long as a person never acted on their sexuality. “You can be this, but … not in any actual tangible way,” Tacher, who is heterosexual, told Uncloseted Media.

When his sibling, who is nonbinary, came out as gay around 2009, Tacher remembers feeling that “something just clicked” in his understanding of them and—over time—he accepted them for who they are.
“They’re just living their life,” Tacher says. “You have a choice how you respond and what you do. That is the only thing you are in control of. And I wanted [to] feel comfortable around them living their life and be comfortable living my own.”
How Religious Beliefs Translate to Familial Rejection
In Okrey’s research, they say LGBTQ participants raised in conservative Christian families often feared coming out to their siblings because of the family’s religious beliefs.
“When you have a highly religious family system, siblings are less likely to have access to a sibling they feel safe coming out to,” Okrey told Uncloseted Media. “When they are not religious, it’s easier to tell how they will react. But in my dataset, which was conservative Christians, they had a lot of fear coming out to siblings because of the religious context of the family.”
For Mike, 45, who asked to be identified only by his first name to protect his familial relationships, the beliefs that divided him from his younger brother emerged during childhood when his parents converted to evangelical Christianity.
When Mike came out to his brother at 30, he was relatively accepting, but only if Mike remained celibate. So after Mike revealed plans to marry a man, his brother sent letters warning that the devil was deceiving him. Mike tried to explain how his beliefs had changed and that he was no longer Christian, but his brother insisted they could not agree to disagree.
According to Mike, his brother also urged their family and mutual friends to stop speaking to him.
“He tried to get my parents not to talk to me anymore,” Mike says. “That’s a little more hurtful than just, ‘I can’t talk to you anymore.’”
Parents Set the Terms
According to experts, parents establish a family’s attitudes toward LGBTQ identities.
“Some people are not willing to go against their parents’ beliefs, that’s just the reality,” Rin Reczek, professor of sociology and co-director of the Center for Aging Families at The Ohio State University, told Uncloseted Media. “It takes a lot to reject one’s parents’ belief, especially in the case of religion.”
A 2026 study of 39 adults estranged from a sibling—17 of whom were LGBTQ—found that 38 of the participants described parental behavior as contributing to the estrangement. Twenty-nine said their own estrangement from a parent had damaged or ended a sibling relationship.
According to Okrey, one of the harmful religious messages that is passed on through parents is the idea that if someone loves their sibling, they will cut them off because it is what is best for their soul.
“That is very specific messaging that parents receive from religion that is then passed on to their children,” Okrey says. “It is taught that you have to do things that feel unloving to save their soul.”
Before Everhart came out as trans, she remembers her older sister warning her as a child to hide the fact that she sometimes wore her clothes. When her father caught her wearing a dress around age 9, Everhart says he called her a homophobic slur and physically assaulted her.
“Parents are the ones who create the family culture in childhood, right?” Reczek says. “They can be the enforcers of the family’s homophobia and transphobia.”
The Costs of Sibling Estrangement
Everhart says the consequences of her family’s rejection stay with her. After years of working through her anger, she has come to believe that her sister’s rejection was rooted in a religious understanding of love: that distancing herself from Everhart might ultimately bring her back to God.
“To them, [they think] they’re loving, but it’s an altered form of love,” she says.
But Okrey says this explanation is hard to accept. “You can’t shake that [rejection] off and move on,” they say. “You will always feel the pain of that betrayal and not accepting the person. You can’t pretend that it is not horrifically painful.”
Reczek says that LGBTQ people often endure years of disrespect, misgendering or rejection in an effort to maintain family ties.
“Queer people try really hard to stay in relationships with their siblings,” she says. “I do not think that the focus on reconciliation and repair is always appropriate. … I also think it’s OK for people to not desire to do that.”
How Siblings Can Learn to Love Their LGBTQ Brothers and Sisters
For the siblings of LGBTQ people who do want to work through things, Reczek says that exposure to queer people and a willingness to reconsider long-held assumptions can help create space for more supportive relationships. Lewis, the sibling therapist, says conversations with more open-minded religious leaders may also help some families reconcile their faith with accepting an LGBTQ relative.

Tacher says that it is a choice to love your sibling and once you choose to, you can get over anything.
“When [my sibling] started doing drag shows, I was really uncomfortable. So I started following ten other drag queens on Instagram to make it more normal,” says Tacher. “Whatever it is about what they’re doing that makes you uncomfortable, try and engage with that in other ways that don’t involve them.”
How Queer People Can Move On
For Everhart, accepting that reconciliation may never come has not erased the grief.
She still cries when she watches “Love, Simon,” a film about a gay teenager whose family is accepting.
“I cry because I was robbed of that supportive family and being able to find myself and being OK with who I am and being told it’s OK,” she says. “Even though we are the only ones left in our immediate family, I don’t think she and I will ever have a relationship. … I am grieving what I never had.”
Reczek says LGBTQ people shouldn’t feel obligated to repair relationships that repeatedly cause them harm. In a 2026 study of 68 estranged adults, Reczek found that participants rebuilt their sense of family through close friendships, supportive older adults and other relatives. A separate study of 46 estranged adults found that safe therapeutic relationships helped participants process difficult emotions, feel validated and develop healthier relationship skills.
Everhart has been in therapy for years and has done extensive work to process her time at the conversion therapy camp.
She says that even if her sister reached out today, she would struggle to believe the gesture was genuine. “I don’t think her and I will ever have a relationship,” she says. “I don’t have any faith in that.”
Everhart has since built a chosen family of people who offer her the care she lacked growing up. One older friend drove to her home on Christmas to assemble her child’s bicycle. Others have stepped into parental roles, offering support and affection without asking her to change who she is. But she is still working through trust issues.
“Do they really care about me? Do they really love me?” she says. “Even though all of their actions in the world show me that, it’s hard to believe because of how I was treated [by my family.]”
Tacher says that overcoming years of religious conditioning isn’t always easy, but it begins with a choice: whether to let inherited beliefs dictate a relationship or make room for a different kind of love.
“They’re just trying to live their own life just like the rest of us are,” he says.