For the LGBTQ Community, Family Brings Extra Benefits and Costs

John Auten-Schneider and David Auten-Schneider came out about their finances about two years after they started dating.

The conversation started while they were looking to buy land in Winter Park, Colorado, to build a weekend home. As they planned, they realized they couldn’t afford to buy land, purchase an existing home or even rent there.

Together, they had more than $50,000 in debt, even though they had more than 15 years of combined experience in financial services at the time.

“It kicked off a conversation of, ‘Why do we know so much and are doing so little?’” John said.

John and David Auten-Schneider on their wedding day. The couple married after more than 13 years together.
John and David Auten-Schneider on their wedding day. The couple married after more than 13 years together.Studio Lemus

The couple realized that growing up gay in communities that didn’t accept them played a part.

“We were using money to make ourselves feel better from the past,” said John, adding that it was also a tool to fit in once they did find the gay community.

Once they addressed those issues and envisioned the future they wanted — a comfortable retirement, means to travel and the ability to give back — they were able to pay off their debt and work toward other goals. They also established protections for each other, such as creating a trust and having health care proxy forms, to solidify their family.

It also brought about a career change. In 2015, the couple started Debt Free Guys, a personal finance site. A year later, they also launched Queer Money, a podcast about financial issues in the LGBTQ community.

They got married in 2017, after more than 13 years together. While they’d already taken steps to be recognized legally as partners, marriage brought further benefits such as tax breaks by filing jointly, survivor rights and access to spousal Social Security benefits if one were to die.

Having a handle on finances is important for LGBTQ individuals, as many start off behind their non-LGBTQ peers. Some may not have had supportive families and incur more debt for education, can face discrimination in the workplace, may need to protect financial assets from family and may experience higher costs associated with family building.

“Putting money aside is going to give you freedoms that a lot of folks don’t have, especially LGBTQ folks,” said John. “The more money you have for your own self and security, the more money and time and energy you can give back to the community.”

Marriage brings benefits and responsibilities

LGBTQ people also face a shifting legal landscape that can add steps in financial and family planning. It was legal to fire someone for being gay or transgender in some states until this year, and LGBTQ couples were only granted the right to legally marry in 2015.

“When you’re married it’s a different set of structures for planning the major issues,” said certified planner Jennifer Hatch, president of Christopher Street Financial, which specializes in LGBTQ finance.

“By marrying someone you become their next of kin — that is very important if people have very little family or hostile family,” Hatch said.



‘A win for all of us’: Over 220 LGBTQ candidates celebrate election victories

Marriage also brings about certain responsibilities, because you’re bound to your partner legally said Hatch. If you’re not married there are things you should do to make sure you protect each other in the event of death, disability or divorce.

As unromantic as those things are, they’re important to plan for, Hatch said, especially for LGBTQ newlyweds that tend to be older than non-LGBTQ peers when they enter a marriage and bring in more assets and potentially children.

Hatch recommends couples have detailed plans for what should happen in the event of death or disability which include medical proxy forms and account access information. In the event of divorce, Hatch says that couples can draw up a pre- or post- nuptial agreement that spells out how assets should be divided and addresses spousal support.

Those documents basically say despite the law, this is how we’re going to manage the relationship, she said.

The price of parenthood is high

LGBTQ people also have a lot of planning to do around building families, which is on the rise in the community. Nearly 80 percent of LGBTQ people aged 18 to 35 are already parents or are thinking about having children, a 44 percent increase over older generations, according to a 2018 survey from Family Equality, a nonprofit organization that aims to advance the rights of LGBTQ families.


OUT NEWSAlito takes aim at gay marriage in ‘politically charged speech’

OUT NEWSEU launches LGBTQ protection strategy as homophobia rises in east

The path to parenthood can be costly and require careful planning as many LGBTQ families plan to expand through foster care, adoption and assisted reproduction technology, according to the survey.

Jess Venable-Novak and their partner, Dory, are in the middle of family planning. The couple married in a small wedding in November 2019 after starting the process of having a sibling for their 7-year-old daughter, Dottie.

“The few gifts we did get for getting married we put right into a savings account for a fertility journey,” said Venable-Novak, who is nonbinary and uses “they” pronouns. The couple has since put any extra money in the same account, such as their tax refund and Covid-19 stimulus checks. Their parents have also helped with expenses.

Jess Venable-Novak and their partner, Dory, have spent more than $15,000 so far in the process of getting pregnant with their second child - a sibling for daughter Dottie.
Jess Venable-Novak and their partner, Dory, have spent more than $15,000 so far in the process of getting pregnant with their second child – a sibling for daughter Dottie.Courtesy Jess Venable-Novak

So far, the Venable-Novaks have spent upwards of $15,000 out of pocket and are not yet pregnant.

“We weren’t anticipating spending this much money when we started,” said Venable-Novak, family engagement manager for Family Equality.

The original plan was for Dory, who will carry the baby, to get pregnant through a process called intrauterine insemination. But after five unsuccessful procedures that cost about $7,000, the family switched to in vitro fertilization, or IVF, which is more expensive.

There are other expenses that the family is saving for at the same time. The couple is working on putting away $6,000 so Dory can take 12 weeks off work after giving birth. Her job only guarantees five weeks of family medical leave with short-term disability pay and the couple is budgeting for legal fees and paperwork for second-parent adoption.

Even though the couple lives in Vermont, where they can both be listed on the baby’s birth certificate, Jess will have to legally adopt the baby to make sure they are recognized as a parent in other states.

They’re also balancing trying to get pregnant with other financial goals, including paying off credit card bills, student loan debt and looking to move.

Deciding to expand their family forced them to take a hard look at finances and talk about their goals, said Venable-Novak. “That was a moment of re-setting and reevaluating,” they said.

The benefits of being financially prepared

There are resources available to help LGBTQ people with financial planning and building a family. Many employers offer benefits for employees looking to create families, such as help with the adoption process, coverage for some fertility treatments or surrogacy fees and paid leave for both primary and secondary parents.

Others offer financial planning help, such as access to advisors or attorneys. John and David were able to see an attorney who helped them with legal documents before they were married by accessing a workplace benefit.



She says the sheriff fired her for being gay. Now, she’ll be the sheriff.

Same-sex couples can also forge their own path when it comes to money and family, as they generally don’t feel pressured to adhere to typical gender roles and are able to be on more equal footing when it comes to a relationship.

“You don’t have to imitate your parents and merge everything,” said Hatch, adding that she recommends a yours, mine and ours approach to finances. For many families, this means having a system that works for them and their unique needs.